The voice came through the brass horn scratchy and thin, as if Elara were speaking from the bottom of a well. Wren sat very still, her hands in her lap, and listened. "Wren. If you're hearing this, you found the log. And I am so, so sorry. I should have told you. I should have sat you down and told you everything. But if I had told you, you would have tried to stop me. And I couldn't let you do that." A pause. The cylinder turned. A scratch. A breath. "I found the log six months after Dad died. You were nineteen. You were still sleeping with his coat on your bed. I couldn't — I couldn't let this place take you too. I investigated. I found the Register. I found the names. I found out what the lamp does. And I confronted Aldous. I went to his house. I told him I knew. I told him I would write to the mainland. To the newspapers. I would burn the whole thing down." Another pause. Wren's hands were clenched in her lap. She did not breathe. "He didn't threaten me. He poured me tea. He told me about his son. And then he said — he said the council had already voted. They had two names on the table, Wren. Mine. And yours. Because I knew, and because you were my sister, and because they couldn't leave a loose thread. He said if I went quietly — if I volunteered — they would erase only me. And you would be made keeper. And you would be safe. Those were the only two options. Both of us, or just me." Wren made a sound. It was not a word. Maren stirred in the bed, but Wren did not look at her. She could not look away from the brass horn. "I chose me. Of course I chose me. You were nineteen. You were still sleeping with Dad's coat. I chose me, and I made him promise — I made him swear — that you would be keeper, and that you would be safe, and that they would never touch you. And then I came home, and I didn't tell you, because if I told you, you would have fought, and you would have lost, and I couldn't — I couldn't lose you, Wren. I couldn't." The voice broke. Just for a moment. Then it steadied. "I am asking you now. Don't bring me back. I mean it. Don't. The cost is too high. They will erase you. They will erase everyone you love. I chose this. I chose it with open eyes. Let me have chosen it. Let it mean something. Live. Be the keeper. Be happy. Forgive me." A long pause. The cylinder turned. The needle scratched. And then, very softly, as if Elara were speaking directly into Wren's ear: "If you do bring me back — I'll be angry. I'll be so angry. But I'll also love you. I always love you. Whatever you decide. I always love you." The cylinder ended. The needle lifted. The room was very quiet. Wren sat. She did not move. The lighthouse beam swept the window, and the kitchen brightened, and faded, and brightened, and faded. Maren was awake now, sitting up in the bed, watching her. Wren did not see her. She had spent three years believing Elara had been taken. Three years grieving a theft. And the truth was — Elara had left. She had chosen to go. She had walked into the light with her eyes open, and she had done it for Wren, and she had asked Wren to let her stay gone. The quest Wren had built her life around — find Elara, bring her home — was built on a lie. Not Aldous's lie. Her own. She had told herself Elara wanted to come back. She had never considered that Elara might not. "Girl," Maren said, softly. "Wren." Wren looked at her. Her face was wet. She had not been crying. She did not know when she had started. "She chose it," Wren said. Her voice was a stranger's. "She chose it, and she told me not to bring her back." Maren got out of bed. She came and sat beside Wren. She did not touch her. She knew better than to touch a person in this kind of cold. "What are you going to do?" Wren thought. She thought for a long time. The lamp turned. The sea sounded. Somewhere far below, the foghorn blew. "She chose it with a gun to her head," Wren said, at last. "Aldous told her: you, or both of you. That's not a choice. That's a sentence. She didn't choose erasure. She chose me. And if I bring her back — if I give her the choice she never had — then she can decide. She can stay gone, if she wants. I'll even help her. But she gets to choose. Not Aldous. Not the council. Her." Maren was quiet. Then she nodded, once. "That's my girl." Wren stood. She went to the window. The village was dark, all but one house: Cree House, on the headland, its windows lit, burning late. Aldous was awake. Aldous knew. He had known, perhaps, that the cylinder existed. He had known Wren would find it. He had let her find it, because he wanted her to hear Elara say don't bring me back. He wanted her to give up. She would not give up. But the ground had shifted under her. She was no longer fighting to rescue a sister who wanted saving. She was fighting to give a sister her choice back. And if Elara, restored, told her to leave it — Wren would have to. That was the new terror. Not losing. Winning, and being told she was wrong. She looked at her forearm, where she had written Elara in ink. The word was smudged. She could not, she realized, match the voice on the cylinder to any memory. She had heard Elara speak, truly, for the first time in three years — and it had sounded like a stranger. The voice she had carried in her head for three years was not Elara's. It was a fiction. The real Elara's voice was on the cylinder, and Wren could not remember it. She picked up the phonograph needle. She rewound the cylinder. She would listen again. She would listen until the voice was hers. And outside, in the dark, the lights of Cree House burned on, and Aldous Cree sat at his desk, and he marked Wren Hollis's name a second time, because he had heard the cylinder too — the map told him when a name was spoken, when a memory was stirred — and he knew, with a tired and terrible certainty, that Wren Hollis would not be dissuaded by her sister's voice. She would have to be erased.
Download Novelah App
You can read more chapters. You'll find other great stories on Novelah.
Book Comment (2)
VMay
i like how u did to the characters. can't wait for the next chapter
18/10
0
beMay
I so much love it! I like the plot. I'll wait for the next chapter.
i like how u did to the characters. can't wait for the next chapter
18/10
0I so much love it! I like the plot. I'll wait for the next chapter.
17/10
0View All