Homepage/Black Hearts and The Untruthful Lies/
Chapter 17 The Day The World Stared Back
The car ride home had a strange kind of stillness.
Arra sat in the passenger seat, her body facing forward, but her senses stretched behind her, tuning in to the lighthearted conversation between Seth and Danica. She wasn’t speaking—not because she had nothing to say, but because she was listening. Truly listening. And something about the way they spoke—the laughter in their voices, the ease between them—wrapped around her like a warm, familiar blanket.
For the first time in days, she felt peace trickle into her chest.
Danica’s giggles filled the quiet cabin. “So wait,” she said, leaning forward slightly from the backseat, “you’re telling me you two are… a couple? Like, together? ”
Her voice wasn’t skeptical, more like surprised. Maybe even a little amazed.
She didn’t wait for an answer before blurting out, “I’m sorry—it’s not that I don’t believe it. I mean, come on—Seth Whitson? I thought you were just a legend people whispered about at school. And now I’m in your car, we’re talking like it’s nothing, and you’re dating Arra? ”
Arra turned slightly, her lips curving into a wry smile. “It’s not what it looks like.”
Danica raised her eyebrows. “What does that mean? ”
Arra sighed softly. “It means he’s not my boyfriend. He’s just… helping me. That’s all.”
“Helping you? ”Danica echoed, disbelieving. “By publicly showing himself? By walking into your old job and threatening to shut it down? I’m sorry, Arra, but nobody does that just to help.”
Seth glanced at Arra and smirked slightly, his tone teasing but sincere. “I guess I haven’t officially asked you yet.”
Arra blinked. “Asked me what? ”
He looked at her, steady and unflinching. “If you’d let me be your boyfriend.”
The question hit her like a wave she hadn’t seen coming. She turned away, suddenly too aware of the weight in her chest.
“How could someone like you want someone like me? ” Her voice cracked slightly. “I’m blind. I’m damaged. I’m not the girl people like you fall for.”
Seth didn’t answer right away. Instead, he reached out and took her hand, lifting it to his lips.
“I’d rather be a fool who loves you than a coward who leaves.”
Silence fell between them again—not the heavy kind from earlier, but something softer, something laced with unsaid emotions and nervous heartbeats.
Danica watched them with a smile tugging at her lips. She didn’t say a word, but her heart warmed at the sight of them. Maybe love didn’t always start the way movies portrayed it. Maybe it looked like this—quiet and messy, but real.
After about ten minutes, Seth turned into a familiar driveway, pulling up outside White Lava Café.
The place was a local treasure, known by every student and resident of Flitcaster. Its cinnamon-apple pies were legendary, and their Forest Fruit tea—a blend of red and black currants, berries, and hibiscus—was practically prescribed for stress relief. It was cozy, warm, and affordable, even for students. What most people didn’t know was that it remained that way because of the Whitson family’s silent generosity.
Years ago, a quiet agreement was struck between the Whitsons and the local government—the family would fund community-friendly prices, especially for students and middle-class patrons, in exchange for privacy. The Whitsons didn’t want recognition or fame. They wanted peace. But if word got out, they knew the reactions would be unpredictable: admiration from some, fear from others.
And fear always came with consequences.
Seth stepped out first, circling to help Arra down from the car. Danica followed closely, wrapping her arms around herself as the scent of roasted spices and warm pastries drifted out from the café.
The three of them walked inside.
As soon as the doors closed behind them, the atmosphere changed.
Conversations died. Forks paused mid-air. Heads turned.
The entire café fell into a stunned, silent trance.
Every eye was on them—or more precisely, on Seth. Some of the students stared with disbelief, others with barely hidden curiosity. A few looked almost fearful.
It had been years since Seth Whitson had made a public appearance like this. And never before with two girls by his side—especially not one like Arra, who didn’t belong to the elite social circles of Flitcaster.
Arra felt the shift in the room instantly. Though she couldn’t see the stares, she felt them—heavy and cold, crawling across her skin like frostbite.
She turned to Seth and whispered, “Are they… staring at me? ”
Seth didn’t answer right away.
“I can feel it,” Arra continued, her voice quiet but serious. “It’s like pins in my spine. I can’t explain it, but it’s making my chest feel tight.”
Danica, standing beside her, tried to brush it off with a small laugh. “You’re probably just being poetic.”
But Seth knew better.
Without saying a word, he raised his hand and caught the attention of a waiter near the bar. The man approached quietly, professional but curious.
“We’ll need a VIP table,” Seth said, handing him a small gold coin.
It wasn’t ordinary currency—this coin was a mark of status, a symbol of hidden power. One side bore a carving of five pentagonal stars encircling a crescent moon. The other side was etched with the image of a nine-tailed fox, the ancient crest of the Whitson bloodline. Only those in the highest tiers of Flitcaster society even knew what the coin meant.
The waiter bowed his head slightly and gestured for them to follow him behind a discreet velvet partition.
Within minutes, they were seated in a quiet, enclosed VIP section. Soundproof. Private.
Safe.
Danica eagerly began flipping through the menu. “I’m starving,” she announced, and placed an order for the top three bestselling dishes without hesitation.
Arra stayed silent.
Her fingers tapped nervously against the edge of the table. Her heart was racing in a way she couldn’t explain—part anxiety, part anticipation, maybe a whisper of fear. Something was off. She could feel it pressing against her ribs like a shadow she couldn’t see.
Seth sat with perfect posture, but his eyes drifted toward the door, his ears tuned in to every sound from the main room.
He could hear everything.
The whispers. The gossip. The sharp, ugly words about his family—about him. They called him a monster. A mistake. A predator hiding behind good looks and wealth.
He clenched his fists under the table, jaw tightening.
But he didn’t say a word.
He couldn’t. Not here. Not now. He wouldn’t ruin this day for Arra—not when she was finally beginning to feel accepted again.
Fifteen minutes passed before their food arrived. The aromas were warm and comforting—roasted garlic, honey-glazed vegetables, and tea steaming in ceramic cups.
Even Seth, despite his supernatural nature, enjoyed human food—though he required something far different during the White Nights. For now, this was enough.
They ate slowly, peacefully.
Until Danica’s phone buzzed.
She glanced at the screen, her expression falling. “It’s my mom. I have to go—she needs me home.”
Seth looked up. “Are you sure? We’re just finishing up. I can drive you.”
She shook her head. “It’s out of the way, and I don’t want to delay you guys. Besides, I think Arra needs rest.”
“I think we should drop you off first,” Arra insisted.
“No, it’s okay. Thank you both—for everything.” Danica leaned over and kissed Arra’s cheek before slipping out quietly, leaving them alone once again.
The drive back to the ranch was filled with silence—not uncomfortable, but heavy.
Arra stared out the window, thoughts whirling. Seth occasionally glanced at her, his mind racing with things he wanted to say but couldn’t. He didn’t know how to break through whatever pain she was still carrying—and maybe she wasn’t ready to let go of it.
But when they reached the ranch, all thoughts of emotional barriers were torn away by something much more brutal.
As soon as Seth stepped out and helped Arra from the car, a figure came rushing toward them—fast and furious.
Mike.
Arra’s father.
Before Seth could react, Mike slammed a fist into his jaw. Then another. And another.
“Seth! Arra!” screamed, clutching his arm. “Dad! Stop it! ”
But Mike didn’t stop. He was a storm of fists and fury. Eliza ran from the porch, screaming, “Mike, stop! What are you doing?! ”
Seth stumbled backward but didn’t raise his hands. He didn’t fight back. He couldn’t—not without hurting someone. Not with Arra around.
He took every punch in silence, his lips bleeding, knees nearly giving out beneath him.
“Dad, please! ” Arra sobbed, pulling at Mike’s arm. “Stop hurting him! ”
Finally, Mike paused, panting heavily. He turned to Eliza and shoved Arra toward her.
“Get her inside,” he barked. “And you—” he pointed at Seth, rage burning in his eyes, “if you ever come near my daughter again, I will kill you with my bare hands. I’ll hunt your whole bloodline down.”
Seth’s voice was hoarse but controlled. “You can’t keep me from her. And you can’t take her away from me.”
Without another word, he climbed back into his car and drove away, the tires crunching the gravel beneath them.
Mike turned on Arra, his face pale and furious. “You think you’re safe with him? I stayed away for years—years—to protect you from that world. And you repay me by making friends with a Whitson?! ”
He dragged her inside, up the stairs, and toward her room.
Arra cried out, “Stop, please! You don’t understand! ”
He didn’t respond.
He threw her into her room, slammed the door, and locked it from the outside.
“You’re not seeing him again. Not while I’m still breathing.”
And then the hallway went silent, leaving Arra alone—shaking, broken, and crumpled on the floor.Download Novelah App
You can read more chapters. You'll find other great stories on Novelah.
Book Comment (26)
Share
Related Chapters
Latest Chapters
good nice
19d
0like it
17/08
0جداً جداً جداً
04/07
0View All