logo text

Chapter 12: The Mercy of Forgetting

He came to the lighthouse at dusk, the night before the steamer was due. He did not knock. He simply stood at the door, in his black coat, with a basket over his arm, and waited for Wren to see him through the kitchen window.
She let him in. She did not know why. Perhaps because, if she did not, he would stand there all night, and she would have to look at him through the glass, and she was tired of looking at things through glass.
"I brought soup," he said, setting the basket on the table. "Eleanor's recipe. You eat too little." He looked around the cottage — the log on the table, the notebook, the two cups by the stove. His eyes did not linger on anything. He was too careful for that. "May I sit?"
They sat. He poured soup. He did not mention the log. He did not mention the oil. He did not mention the note. He ate his soup, and Wren ate hers, and the lighthouse turned above them, slow and steady, and the foghorn sounded far below.
"You are wondering why I am here," Aldous said, at last.
"I am wondering why you brought soup."
He smiled. It reached his eyes, briefly. "Because I am old, and I am tired, and I do not wish to be the villain of your story." He set down his spoon. "I want to show you something. At my house. Will you come?"
She went. She told herself it was because she wanted to see. She told herself it was because knowledge was power. She did not tell herself it was because, for a moment, sitting across from him at the table, she had felt almost like a daughter.
Cree House was cold. He lit no fire. He led her up the stairs, past the photographs of Eleanor, to a door at the end of the landing. He opened it.
The room was a boy's room. A cricket bat in the corner. A shelf of books, half-read, spines cracked. A pair of boots by the bed, caked with mud. A photograph on the nightstand — faded, almost blank, the face gone to a smudge. Dust sheets over the furniture, but the dust was thin, as if someone came in sometimes and walked around, and did not touch anything.
"Caleb," Aldous said. He stood in the doorway. He did not enter. "He was nineteen. Quick with his fists. Quick with his heart, too, though not many saw it. He got into a fight at the harbour. A man named Tomás Reed. Caleb hit him. He fell. His head struck the jetty. He died."
Wren said nothing. She looked at the boots. The mud was still on them, dried, ten years old.
"The Reed family," Aldous said, "vowed blood. Old country ways. They would have killed Caleb. And then someone on our side would have killed one of theirs. And on, and on. I could see it. I could see the next twenty years, and they were all graves." He paused. His left hand, at his side, began to tremble. He put it behind his back. "I went to the council. I asked them. I begged them. Take him. Erase him. The feud would die with him. No one would remember Tomás Reed. No one would remember the fight. It would be as if it never happened."
"And was it?"
"Was it what?"
"As if it never happened."
Aldous was quiet for a long time. "The feud ended," he said. "The Reeds forgot. The town forgot. Caleb — went away. That part worked." He looked at the photograph on the nightstand, the blank face. "Eleanor forgot him. Entirely. She woke up one morning and did not know why there was a boy's room at the top of the stairs. I told her it was a spare room. She believed me. She died two years later. The doctor said her heart. I think — I think she grieved, even when she did not know what she was grieving. The body remembers, Wren. The body keeps its own ledger."
He turned to her. His pale eyes were wet. "I keep one memory. The light lets me keep one. I hear him laugh. Sometimes, in the night, I hear my son laugh, and I cannot remember his face, and I do not know which is worse — the remembering or the forgetting."
Wren's throat was tight. She did not trust it. She did not trust the pity she felt. Pity was a door, and Aldous was very good at walking through doors.
"The steamer comes tomorrow," Aldous said. "Take it. Take the log, take your sister's things, take whatever you want. Go to the mainland. Build a new life. I will tell the council you left. I will withdraw your name. You will be safe."
"And Elara?"
"Elara chose her path." Aldous's voice was gentle. "You cannot bring her back, Wren. Even if you could — she chose this. Would you undo a choice your sister made? Would you force her back into a world she chose to leave?"
Wren's hands curled into fists. He knew. He knew she had found the restoration rule, or he guessed it, and he was using it against her. She chose this. Would you undo it? The same question she had been asking herself since the town hall.
"I will not leave," she said.
Aldous nodded slowly. He looked — not angry. Sad. Deeply, tiredly sad. "Then I cannot protect you," he said. "The council will vote. They have already voted, in their hearts. And on the full moon, I will go to the lamp, and I will speak your name three times, and you will be gone, and I will keep one memory of you, and it will torture me for the rest of my life. I am asking you now, as one human being to another — do not make me do that."
He left. He walked down the drive and into the dark, and Wren stood in the doorway of Caleb's room and watched him go, and she thought: He means it. Every word. He believes erasure is mercy. He believes he is saving me.
That was the horror of it. He was not a monster. He was a man who had loved his son and had made a terrible choice and had spent ten years convincing himself it had been kind. And he would never, ever stop — because to stop would be to admit that Caleb had died for nothing, and that Eleanor had died for nothing, and that his hands were dirty.
She went home. She wrote in her notebook, carefully, before she could forget: Caleb Cree. Aldous's son. Erased 10 years ago. Killed Tomás Reed. Aldous believes forgetting is mercy.
In the morning, she read the line. She could not remember who Caleb was. She could not remember the boy's room, the boots, the faded photograph. She read the words, and they were strangers to her, and she understood then that the light was not just taking Elara. It was taking everything. It would leave her with nothing but the notebook, and one day she would forget how to read.
She closed the notebook. She put it in the drawer, under her father's charts. She went and lit the lamp, and she counted the 88 steps — eighty-six, eighty-seven, eighty-eight — and she did not tell herself that everything would be all right, because she did not lie to herself anymore.

Book Comment (2)

  • avatar
    VMay

    i like how u did to the characters. can't wait for the next chapter

    18/10

      0
  • avatar
    beMay

    I so much love it! I like the plot. I'll wait for the next chapter.

    17/10

      0
  • View All

Related Chapters

Latest Chapters